Conclusions may be clear but entirely inaccurate
because your survey items are not measuring what you intended
for them to measure. This can have disastrous consequences
on your business- especially if you use survey results to
influence business decisions. It is in these circumstances
that the accuracy of your research is essential. With Infosoft
Research you have the piece of mind knowing that our measurement
consultants primary concerns are validity and integrity of
your data
Factors that can threaten the validity of your
results fall into three broad categories:
1. Survey Construction
2. Survey Administration
3. Analysis and Interpretation
Below contains some frequently asked questions
and common pitfalls regarding survey construction and analysis.
Feel free to give us a call or email us if you have questions:
+1 360.714.0831 email: analytics@infosoftresearch.com
HOW SHOULD I PHRASE THE
SURVEY ITEM?
Survey items can be constructed as questions or statements.
Example:
Did you feel that customer phone support was attentive to
your needs?
Customer phone support was attentive to your needs.
What is most important here is that biases are minimized.
If the item "leads" the respondent to answer in
a particular way there is probably a better way to phrase
it.
DOUBLE-BARRELED ITEMS
This is a common pitfall that makes it almost impossible to
interpret a respondent's answer. The problem occurs when a
single survey item addresses two separate issues.
Examples:
1. I believe my benefits and retirement packages are fair.
2. The site was helpful and easy to navigate.
In example one respondents may be referring to either the
benefits package or retirement package or both. The item should
be restructured so that one survey item assesses the perceived
fairness of the benefits package and a second survey item
assesses the perceived fairness of retirement package. In
the second example it is unclear whether the survey item refers
to the usefulness of information provided on the site, or
the overall ease of navigability of the site. Again, the solution
is to address only one issue per item.
ORDER EFFECTS
These occur when one survey item effects the interpretation
and response of the following survey item.
Example:
Overall, my impression of the site was positive.
It was difficult to navigate the website.
In the above example, the respondent's overall evaluation
of the site will influence subsequent responses about specific
aspects of the site such as navigation. One way to minimize
order effects is to place specific statements earlier in your
survey, and more general questions toward the end of your
survey. A more traditional solution is to "counter-balance"
the item or randomize the order of presentation.
RESPONSE OPTIONS
There are variety of response options that can be used such
as: open-ended, yes-no, true-false, 4-point scales, and 5-point
scales. You may ask yourself, "Should the survey use
four response options ranging from strongly agree to strongly
disagree or should there be five response options with a neutral
point?" There is no definitive answer to this question
because biases are introduced in both cases. For example,
with 4-point response options, the respondent is forced to
take a position when they may actually think or feel neutrally
about the situation. With 5-point response options, the respondent
may fall back on responding neutrally when they have a definite
position on the matter, but do not want to express it. Ultimately,
the goal is to minimize the bias that is most detrimental
to your study.
ITEM DIRECTION
Should a survey item be worded positively? Negatively? Or
Neutrally?
Example:
I was satisfied with the customer support I received.
I was not satisfied with the customer support I received.
How satisfied were you with the customer support you received?
Ideally, you should use neutral statements so you aren't leading
an individual to respond a certain way. However positively
and negatively worded items are frequently used. The most
important consideration is balance. If there are negatively
worded items then there should be an equal number of positively
worded items as well.
Sampling Considerations
Suppose you are trying to determine people's impression of
your retail mountain climbing gear Web site. It would not
be appropriate to ask a group of people who are not interested
in climbing mountains to complete your survey. Nor would it
make sense to administer the survey to a group of people that
will never shop at your site. Analyzing data and making business
decisions based on opinions from either of those groups may
take your business backwards.
Sampling considerations take into account meaningful questions
including, but not limited to:
1. Who is your target population?
2. How will you reach your target population?
3. Will the way you reach your target population unintentionally
exclude certain members of that population?
4. How will you minimize biases and over- or under- representation
of various age groups, cultural groups, income groups or occupational
groups?
Statistical Analysis:
It is important that you know how you want to analyze the
data before constructing the survey. The kind of analysis
is directly related to overall research objectives of the
survey and what questions you plan to answer as a result of
the survey. It is essential that statistical assumptions (properties
of the data that have an important influence on the validity
of a statistic) are met prior to analyzing the data. Two types
of statistical analyses are Descriptive Analysis and Inferential
Analysis
Inferential Analysis provides that extra information,
revealing if relationships are different enough (or similar
enough) to warrant impacting your business decisions. Inferential
Analysis involves applying statistics to the data to draw
more general conclusions about the overall population. These
conclusions may be based on the relationship between two topics.
For example, a customer satisfaction survey
may center around two "satisfaction factors"- which
can be derived using a statistical procedure known as factor
analysis. These factors may be the core of what satisfies
your customers. There are variables that predict satisfaction
- which can be identified with another statistical modeling
procedure known as multiple regression. Understanding which
factors contribute to overall customer satisfaction and identifying
the variables that predict satisfaction will reveal what is
and is not working in your business.
Let us analyze your survey data for you. We will compile the
results and mine the data using the appropriate statistical
procedures and provide you with a practical, straightforward
report with tables and graphs that you can use for your presentations.
Descriptive Statistics: There are a wide range of statistics
that are used to describe or summarize data. Most tables in
survey reports present descriptive statistics for one or more
groups or sub-groups among the respondents. For surveys, these
usually are limited to either the the various percentages
of respondents who select from a range of categorical alternatives
(e.g., "Very Dissatisfied" to "Very Satisfied",
women v. men, position in the company, etc.) or as averages
(mean) or median (and percentile) scores on items. Descriptive
statistics computed for sample data (survey respondents) are
used as estimates for the target population (e.g., all customers
or employees) and as such, they should be accompanied by estimates
of the margin of error or of the confidence interval that
give some indication that is useful for gauging how accurate
these descriptions are.
Tests for Significant
Differences: Usually, tests for significant differences
are conducted to examine changes that occur over time or differences
between groups or subgroups. Which specific procedures are
used will depend on the type of measurement scale used for
the survey items under scrutiny. Differences in categorical
data, for example, may be analyzed using a procedure called
Chi2 and differences in average (mean) scores may be analyzed
using procedures such as the t-test or the analysis of variance.
By consensus, differences that are unlikely to be the result
of chance fluctuations in the data alone (defined as a less
than 0.05 probability) are referred to as statistically significant.
Alternatively, you can also examine margins of error or confidence
intervals for two groups or subgroups; if they do not overlap,
the differences are likely to be statistically significant
using other tests.
Statistical Modeling:
There are a variety of procedures from simple correlations
between items to more elaborate statistical techniques that
allow researchers to evaluate how items relate to other items,
individually or jointly. Regression analysis and more complex
statistical modeling procedures are based on the intercorrelations
among items and can be used to identify clusters of items
that fall together into single dimensions (e.g., which items
appear to reflect loyalty?) and to relate these items or dimensions
to desired outcomes (e.g., how do satisfaction with compensation,
opportunities for advancement, and the effectiveness of organizational
communications and other factors relate to employee loyalty
and commitment?). If you have a large enough sample (generally
a few hundred or more respondents) these techniques can help
you to develop a useful model of how your business objectives
can be achieved.
|